Kurt April
Professor
Necessary Imperfection to enact change
You are the change
Being of service
To the world
Others
Requires not a sense of belonging
Requisite imperfection, vitality required
Energy from the world’s dark abyss
Bourne out of necessary suffering
Out of disconnection, across boundaries
With vision – granted
While being in the world
Seeing the lack of flow
Not fully aligned with the world
You – flutter
Vision enacted
Broken it may be
Wounded you remain
But stepping forward
The sun will shine
For others
For your own soul
No substitute for the imperfect you.
Perfectionism speaks to a mindset of constant moving, of never arriving, unyielding, and if one ever achieves it, an ultimate prize of a finished state without any flaws or errors. It encourages a disdain for imperfection in ourselves and others. We get angry with ourselves and others for not meeting the supposed standard. It emanates from a place of: (1) judgement (“As I am now, is not good enough”), and (2) comparison (“There is always something, or someone, better or worse than me”). Leadership literature is filled with development techniques to help individuals on a pathway to perfection – to fix this, to change that, to cut out those – engendering a life of perpetual unease with ourselves – and to gloss over or even hide those things/experiences that may cause us to appear flawed, imperfect or broken to others. The Japanese concept of wabi sabi, embedded in Zen Buddhism philosophy, conveys a complex set of meanings which can best be summarised as an appreciation of the impermanence, asymmetry and small details in life and everything that surrounds us. Wabi sabi gives us a more constructive lens for thinking about leadership, and the acceptance of transience and imperfection – a liberation from the caves of opinion and comparison. Wabi sabi philosophy is also beautifully expressed in a practice of fixing broken pottery with gold called kintsugi. Here, a broken object is carefully mended back together and the cracks are not just repaired with glue, but further enhanced and decorated with gold or silver. Rather than lamenting over a precious object being broken, the object is not only repaired but made more beautiful in a process. The so-called imperfection actually enriches the original object, and appears even more beautiful. Kintsugi is a powerful metaphor for overcoming hardship, trauma, loss and approaching our own perceived imperfections, weaknesses and traits which we may see as undesirable. Things, and people, are often much stronger and more unique when emerging, or bouncing back, from struggle, suffering or brokenness. In kintsugi, breakage is an essential part of our true history, and not something to disguise. We all bear scars from adverse conditions in our lives and our relationships – and this could be our very gifts to the world later on in life, e.g., having overcome social injustice, one might spend part of one’s life fighting for social justice, for looking our for the most vulnerable or marginalized in society, or having come from poverty one may find the connection and strength to help those currently in poverty or our of work – our so-called scars or imperfections in our history/lives, can become our actual gifts to the world.